a) Is
Fraternization Harmful to Good Order & Discipline?
b) Legal (JAG)
Disposition of Fraternization Should be Same Standard Despite
Rank.
February 2011
Compiled by Bibliography Branch
Muir S. Fairchild Research
Information Center
Maxwell AFB, AL
The appearance of hyperlinks does not constitute endorsement by the U.S. Air Force of the Web site or the information, products, or services contained therein. For other than authorized activities such as military exchanges and morale, welfare and recreation sites, the U.S. Air Force does not exercise any editorial control over the information you may find at these locations. Such links are provided consistent with the stated purpose of this DoD Web site.
Some materials listed below require access to subscription databases. If you cannot gain access, contact your local library for availability. AU students and faculty can contact AUL's Web Maintainer for a password.
If a file does not open by clicking on the link, right click and select "copy the shortcut" then paste it into the browser's address bar.
All sites listed were last accessed on February 7, 2011.
Internet Resources
Army Regulation 600-20. Army Command
Policy. March 18, 2008. 134 p. Department of the Army Pamphlet 600-35.
Relationships Between Soldiers of Different Rank.
February 21, 2000. 18 p. Manual for Courts Martial (2008 Edition). OPNAV Instruction 5370.2C. Navy
Fraternization Policy. April 26, 2007. U.S. Department of Defense: Services
Fraternization Policies. Books
United States. Congress. House. Committee on Armed
Services. Title 10, United States Code: Armed Forces (as
amended through December 31, 1998). Washington, U.S. G.P.O., 1999. 1882 p. Matusak, George J., III. Analysis of
Factors Influencing Tolerance of Fraternization. Wright-Patterson
AFB, OH, Air Force Institute of Technology, 2001. 79 p. Russell, Jeffrey C. An History of the
Development of Fraternization Policies. Wright-Patterson AFB, OH,
Air Force Institute of Technology, 1998. 50 p. Urdzik, Christopher J. Sexual Ethics,
Organizational Climate, and the Air Expeditionary Force. Maxwell
AFB, AL, Air Command and Staff College, 2005. 32 p. Periodicals
Bacon, Lance M. CNO: Peers Must Keep Eye
Out. Navy Times 59:22 April 5, 2010. Butts, Peter W. Contract Oversight on the
Battlefield. Army Sustainment 42:34-37
November-December 2010. Cavallaro, Gina. Sex, Lies and Basic
Training: Leonard Wood Cases Top List of Trainee Abuse by Instructors.
Army Times 69:8-10 December 15, 2008. Ewing, Philip. 13th Skipper Fired.
Navy Times 59:18 September 6, 2010. Fontaine, Scott. Facebook: Fraternization or
Useful Communication? Air Force Times 71:28-29
November 15, 2010. Fraternization Policy Update Reflects Current
Operational Tempo. All Hands No. 1083:6 July
2007. Fuentes, Gidget. Maj. Faces Assault,
Fraternization Charges. Marine Corps Times 12:20
August 16, 2010. Fuentes, Gidget. Skipper-XO Fraternization
Gets Both Fired. Navy Times 60:16 December 20,
2010. Fuentes, Gidget. Star in Recruiting Videos
Kicked Out of Corps. Marine Corps Times 13:25 January
17, 2011. Gaudiano, Nicole. Illegal Affairs: The
Services Top Lawyer Didn't Follow His Own Rules. Air Force
Times 65:16-17 January 3, 2005. Jackson, Jon S. Improper Superior
Subordinate Relationships and Fraternization: Marriage and Change in
Status. The Army Lawyer No. 397:70-73 June
2006. McMichael, William H. Amphib's Top Sailor
Fired for Fraternization. Navy Times 60:21 November
1, 2010. McMichael, William H. Former CPO Maintains
His Innocence after "Frat" Ruling. Navy Times
55:15-16 January 30, 2006. Palomino, Jeffrey G. Kelly Who?
Refreshing the JAG Recollection of the Media, the Air Force, and the First
Court-Martial of Public Opinion. The Reporter
37:22-25 Spring 2010. Rolfsen, Bruce. Favoritism to Subordinate
got Wing Commander Fired. Air Force Times 70:20 May
31, 2010. Rose, Charles H., III. Rank Relationship:
Charging Offenses Arising from Improper Superior-Subordinate
Relationships. Army Lawyer 341:86-92 April
2001. Scutro, Andrew. Chaplain Faces
Accusers--Officer Charged with Rape, Harassment, Adultery.
Navy Times 57:8-10 August 4, 2008. Scutro, Andrew. Chaplain Gets 10 Years in
Brig for Assault, Adultery. Navy Times 58:22 June 15,
2009. Tilghman, Andrew. 7 Sacked in DDG
Scandal. Navy Times 59:16 December 14, 2009. Tilghman, Andrew. Amphib CO, XO Sacked in
Fraternization Case. Navy Times 59:21 December 21,
2009. Tilghman, Andrew. Hammer Falls on
Fraternizing: Spate of Firings Reflects Cultural Shift, Tougher Climate for
Leaders, Many Say. Navy Times 59:22-24 April 5,
2010.
Includes Rapid Action Revision (RAR)
issued April 27, 2010. See Paragraph 4-16, Fraternization.
Available online at: http://armypubs.army.mil/epubs/pdf/r600_20.pdf
Provides guidance and examples about relationships
between soldiers of different rank in the United States Army.
Available
online at: http://armypubs.army.mil/epubs/pdf/P600_35.PDF
Available online at: http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/law/mcm.pdf
See Part IV: Punitive Articles for full-text of Article 133,
Conduct Unbecoming an Officer and a Gentleman, and Article 134, General Article
(Fraternization).
Available
online at: http://doni.daps.dla.mil
Available online at: http://www.defense.gov/specials/fraternization
Official
Department of Defense site contains a breakdown of the individual service
fraternization policies, including each services' definition of fraternization
and examples of prohibited relationships.
Chapter 47, Uniform Code of Military Justice,
Sections 801-940 (Articles 1-140), pp. 260-336.
This thesis
explores several factors that might explain discrepancies in the tolerance level
of fraternization among company grade officers within the Air Force, including
the nature of the relationship, the sex of the participants, whether the
incident occurred between people in the same chain of command, and whether the
survey respondent was ever stationed at a remote location.
Also available
online at: http://handle.dtic.mil/100.2/ADA390778
Doc.
call no.: M-U 39567-5 M445a
Also available online
at: http://handle.dtic.mil/100.2/ADA354245
Doc.
call no.: M-U 39567-4 R964h
"In the last 10
years, three major factors have combined to make sexual misconduct an increasing
topic of concern for the USAF--the Air Expeditionary Force (AEF) rotation cycle,
the steadily increasing gender mix serving on active duty, and additional combat
roles that have opened to women." - Article.
Also available online at: http://handle.dtic.mil/100.2/ADA476183
Doc.
call no.: M-U 43122 U74s
The article
focuses on the message from US Chief of Naval Operations (CNO) Admiral Gary
Roughead issued on March 23, 2010, regarding the issue of fraternization in the
US Navy, calling sailors and officers to look out for one another and report any
inappropriate relationship found.
"The article offers information on the creation of
the team-effort relationship of the Government employee and the contractor...It
adds that the failure of the mission can be contributed to by complacency and
fraternization." - Abstract.
Also available online at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=f5h&AN=55619012&site=ehost-live
The article reports on
the 12 drill sergeants and advanced individual training instructors at Fort
Leonard Wood, Missouri that were involved in forbidden sexual and social
relationships with trainees.
Also available online at: NewsBank
The Navy fired its 13th
skipper of the year when yet another CO was found guilty of 'inappropriate
relationships' with people in her command.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
The article considers whether the use of Facebook may be
thought of as a form of fraternization, an act of socializing with superiors or
subordinates which is prohibited under US military law.
Also available
online at:
NewsBank
The article presents information on the update of the US Navy's
fraternization policy, clarifying what relationships are appropriate for
Sailors.
Also available online at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=mth&AN=25922340&site=ehost-live
A Marine major once featured in officer recruiting videos is
accused of punching two women.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
The article reports on the announcement issued by the US Navy that it
has dismissed Lieutenant Commanders James Rushton and Anne Laird of the ship
Chief on December 8, for violation of the fraternization policy of the
service.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
A Major once featured in Marine Corps officer recruiting videos
will be separated from the service after admitting he took "semi-nude"
photographs of an enlisted subordinate.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
Major General Thomas Fiscus, known
for harsh punishment for fraternization, is himself charged. Includes
comparison of officer and enlisted punishments for fraternization.
Also
available online at:
NewsBank
The article offers advice to military judge advocates (JA) in the US
regarding improper superior subordinate relationships.
Also available online
at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=f5h&AN=22600713&site=ehost-live
The article reports that US Command Master Chief (SW) Robert
Stocklin was relieved on October 21, 2010, after he was found guilty of
violating Article 92 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, which prohibits
fraternization with a female shipmate.
Also available online
at:
NewsBank
The article focuses on the sentence imposed on US
Information Systems Technician 1st Class Jeff McSweeney in relation to the
fraternization and adultery charges filed against him.
Also available online
at:
NewsBank
Also available online at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=f5h&AN=52466386&site=ehost-live
"A wing commander lost his job because he not only played favorites
but hid unfavorable information from his bosses about a female lieutenant
colonel, and recommended her for promotion, according to an Air Force
investigation." - Article.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
Focuses on United States Army policy on improper superior-subordinate
relationships.
Also available online at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=mth&AN=4766981&site=ehost-live
The article reports that
US Navy Lieutenant Shane R. Dillman is facing five charges with multiple
specifications, including rape, harassment, adultery, fraternization, making
threats and indecent exposure.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
The article reports on the confinement of 10 years and dismissal
imposed on US Navy Lieutenant Shane Dillman after being found guilty of sexual
assault, fraternization and adultery with female sailors.
Also available
online at:
NewsBank
This
article focuses on fraternization and a sexual assault allegation on the US
destroyer James W. Williams, which resulted in the dismissal of Commander Paul
Marquis and Command Master Chief Timothy Youell. The two leaders were not
involved in the scandal but were blamed for the poor climate on the
destroyer.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
The article reports that US Navy Commander Christopher Stopyra of the
dock landing ship Fort McHenry was fired for fraternizing with his executive
officer (XO) Lieutenant Commander Brian P. Goldschmidt.
Also available online
at:
NewsBank
The article focuses on a string of fraternization-related punishments
in the US Navy since December 2009.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
Tougher Rules. Navy
Times 59:22 April 5, 2010.
Summary of Navy fraternization
regulations.
Also available online at:
NewsBank
Turney, Paul H. Relations Among the Ranks:
Observations of and Comparisons Among the Service Policies and Fraternization
Case Law, 1999. Army Lawyer 329:97-107 April
2000.
Focuses on rules governing relations among members of the US Armed
Forces.
Also available online at: http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=mth&AN=3107613&site=ehost-live
Air Force Instruction 36-2909.
Professional and Unprofessional Relationships. May 1, 1999.
9 p. Air Force Instruction 36-2909, Supplement 1.
Professional and Unprofessional Relationships. August 13, 2004.
11 p.
This page was last updated on
03/21/2011 07:06 AM
Print version is available in Authority Collection.
Also
available online at: http://www.e-publishing.af.mil/shared/media/epubs/AFI36-2909.pdf
Supplement 1 implements and extends the guidance for AFI
36-2909, Professional and Unprofessional Relationships, dated May 1, 1999.
Incorporates changes from July 8, 2010.
Print version is available in
Authority Collection.
Also available online at: http://www.e-publishing.af.mil/shared/media/epubs/AFI36-2909_USAFASUP1_I.pdf
Return to Fairchild
Center's OTS Advocacy Briefing Support Page